Penn Badgley
Joe Goldberg (10 eps)
Elizabeth Lail
Guinevere Beck (10 eps)
Luca Padovan
Paco (10 eps)
Zach Cherry
Ethan Russell (10 eps)
Shay Mitchell
Peach Salinger (10 eps)
Kathryn Gallagher
Annika (8 eps)
Daniel Cosgrove
Ron (6 eps)
Victoria Cartagena
Claudia (5 eps)
Mark Blum
Mr. Mooney (4 eps)
Hari Nef
Blythe (4 eps)
John Stamos
Dr. Nicky (4 eps)
Lou Taylor Pucci
Benji (3 eps)
Gianni Ciardiello
Young Joe Goldberg (3 eps)
Reg Rogers
Professor Paul Leahy (2 eps)
Christine Toy Johnson
Allison Mott (2 eps)
Michael Maize
Officer Nico (2 eps)
Natalie Paul
Karen Minty (2 eps)
Manini Gupta
Maddie (2 eps)
Michael Park
Edwin Beck (2 eps)
Ryan Andes
Ross (2 eps)
Cliff Moylan
Gas Company Man (1 eps)
Katy Rea
Neo-Folk Singer (1 eps)
Mehdi Barakchian
Middle-Aged Brooklynite (1 eps)
Michael Lewis
Homeless Man (1 eps)
Patrick K. Dooley
Drunk Man (1 eps)
Shehzad
Johno (1 eps)
T.J. Atoms
Candy Store MC (1 eps)
Venida Evans
Older Woman (1 eps)
Kacey Carrig
Bartender (1 eps)
Ben Getz
Tomas (1 eps)
Ethan Itzkow
Yuri (1 eps)
Sean David Cooper
Officer Martin (1 eps)
Jamar Greene
Officer Warren (1 eps)
Laura Chaneski
Hiker (1 eps)
Mercedes Griffeth
Mia (1 eps)
Emily Bergl
Nancy (1 eps)
James DeFilippi
Cooper (1 eps)
Luke David Young
Robert Sawyer (1 eps)
Damion J. Williams
Wedonite (1 eps)
James P. Rees
Bed-Bug Inspector (1 eps)
Reggie Gowland
Roger Stevens (1 eps)
Gerrard Lobo
Raj (1 eps)
Esteban Benito
Elijah (1 eps)
Jo Yang
Bridey (1 eps)
Diana Bologna
Officer Laurel (1 eps)
Kisha Barr
Reporter #1 (1 eps)
Ariel Kim
Bookstore Customer (1 eps)