Holmes
Kelly Mallet (27 eps)
Sam Straley
Lloyd 'Shrub' Mallet (27 eps)
Seann William Scott
Joseph 'Father Joe' Binghoffer (27 eps)
Justin Linville
Mickey St. Jean (27 eps)
Krystal Smith
Mandy 'Big Mandy' Matthews (27 eps)
Aya Cash
Cheryl Peterson (27 eps)
Taylor Ortega
Nadine Garcia-Parney (27 eps)
Karen Huie
June (19 eps)
William Tokarsky
Len (17 eps)
Erin Bowles
Beth (14 eps)
Jaime Pressly
Barb Flatch (13 eps)
Kyle Selig
Dylan (10 eps)
Sheila M. O'Rear
Leotha (9 eps)
Banks Repeta
Levi (8 eps)
Jason MacDonald
Bobby (5 eps)
Weldon Sipe
Mr. Piswall (5 eps)
Heather Rule
Jessie (3 eps)
James 'Jimbo' Tibbetts
Fargas (3 eps)
Taylor Grace Boughton
Map Buying Kid (2 eps)
Parker E. Chick
Young Kelly (2 eps)
Ed Wagenseller
Sheriff's Deputy (2 eps)
Troy Hammond
Blind Billy (2 eps)
Shane Callahan
Dave (2 eps)
Alisa Harris
Sheriff (2 eps)
Desmin Borges
Jimmy (2 eps)
Peggy Sheffield
Linda (2 eps)
Josh Warren
Robot Scarecrow (1 eps)
Austin Alexander
Matt (1 eps)
Timmy Sherrill
Beth's Dad (1 eps)
Gabriella Cila
Angry Girl #1 (1 eps)
Taylor McCall Moore
Angry Girl #2 (1 eps)
Jason Battle
Angry Guy (1 eps)
Lee Armstrong
S. Perkins / D. Perkins (1 eps)
Bayne Gibby
Laura (1 eps)
Zele Avradopoulos
Art Teacher (1 eps)
Gillie Jones
Shelly (1 eps)
Murray Hill
Murray (1 eps)
Jack B. Young
Young Dylan (1 eps)
Rebekah Yang
Waiter (1 eps)
Ginny MacColl
Kelly's Grandma (1 eps)
Clayton Frank
Bus Boy (1 eps)
Martina Litty
Nadine's Friend (1 eps)
Amanda Nicholas
Cynthia (1 eps)
Sean Michael Weber
Young Guy (1 eps)
Mary Lou Faircloth
Bessie (1 eps)
Louise Quince Harrison
Luanne (1 eps)
Chad Michael Baird
Flatch Town Local (1 eps)
Kurt Roberson
Guy (1 eps)
Craig Newkirk
Chris Warner (1 eps)
Joan Reilly
Motorist (1 eps)
Kent West
Townsperson #2 (1 eps)
Jana Allen
Parishioner (1 eps)
Jenique Bennett
Nurse (1 eps)
Omer Mughal
Jordan (1 eps)
Rakesh Gosain
Maintenance Man (1 eps)
Robert Walker Branchaud
Daniel (1 eps)
Trent Mayo
Rodney (1 eps)
Jason McDonald
Bobby (1 eps)
Aldan Karanovich
Aldous (1 eps)
Gabe Wood
Townsperson #1 (1 eps)
Rob Covington
Foreman (1 eps)
Affion Crockett
Julius (1 eps)
Kate Kneeland
Maureen (1 eps)
Daniel Johnson
Coworker (1 eps)
D.W. Moffett
Doug (1 eps)
Derek Evans
Tim (1 eps)
Lulu Picart
Jen (1 eps)
Martin Herlihy
Chris Jordan (1 eps)
Indy Sullivan Groudis
Boy (1 eps)
Townsend Fallica
Young Boy (1 eps)
Henry Freshwater
Ashlynn #1 (1 eps)
Helen Rose Smith
Ashlynn #2 (1 eps)
Kurt Hockenberry
Fireman (1 eps)
Artemis Pebdani
Lola (1 eps)
Ginger Curl
Marlene (1 eps)
Stella Threatt
Baby Ashlynn #1 (1 eps)
Ellie Threatt
Baby Ashlynn #2 (1 eps)
Ron Blake
Featured Parade Bass Drummer (uncredited) (1 eps)
Shane Burnett
Flatchian (uncredited) (1 eps)
Logan Newkirk
Featured Parade Member (uncredited) (1 eps)
Andrew Brooks
Ice Cream Man (uncredited) (1 eps)
Donick Cary
Chris Warner (1 eps)
William G. Tomek
Pedestrian (uncredited) (1 eps)
Michael Sokol
Charlie (1 eps)
Sunny Williams
Candace (1 eps)
Rebekah Kostyal
Laughing Woman #1 (1 eps)
Mennelly
Laughing Woman #2 (1 eps)
Keeley Kollmann
Realtor (uncredited) (1 eps)
Atkins Estimond
Psychic (1 eps)
Mitch Eakins
Rick "The Hot Hermit" (1 eps)
Pat Dortch
Maynard (1 eps)
Heather Magee
Ohio Influencer (1 eps)
Adam Ray
Bert (1 eps)
Ricky Wayne
Stan (1 eps)
Brooke Jaye Taylor
Dr. Newton (1 eps)
Montrel Miller
Emcee (1 eps)
Carole Kaboya
Realtor (1 eps)
Jordan Aaron Ford
Clerk (1 eps)
Stephen Branson
Flatchian (uncredited) (1 eps)
Derrick Etienne Jr.
Derrick Etienne (1 eps)
Whit Blanchard
Lloyd Mallet Esq. (1 eps)
Ava Gail Prince
Flatch Kid (1 eps)
Nathan Penrose
Toy Drive Attendee (uncredited) (1 eps)
Derek Richardson
Lloyd Bush (1 eps)
Cate Freedman
Renee (1 eps)