Tim Allen
Scott Calvin / Santa Claus (12 eps)
Elizabeth Mitchell
Carol Calvin / Mrs. Claus (12 eps)
Austin Kane
Cal Calvin Claus (12 eps)
Elizabeth Allen-Dick
Sandra Calvin Claus (12 eps)
Devin Bright
Noel (12 eps)
Matilda Lawler
Betty (12 eps)
Kal Penn
Simon Choksi (6 eps)
Rupali Redd
Grace Choksi (6 eps)
Gabriel Iglesias
Kris Kringle (6 eps)
Eric Stonestreet
Magnus Antas (6 eps)
Isabella Bennett
Edie (6 eps)
Liam Kyle
Gary (6 eps)
Ruby Jay
Riley (6 eps)
Laura San Giacomo
La Befana (5 eps)
Marta Timofeeva
Olga (5 eps)
Sasha Knight
Crouton (4 eps)
Mia Lynn Bangunan
Pontoon (3 eps)
Izaac Wang
Hugo (2 eps)
Latarsha Rose
Olivia (2 eps)
Serenity Garcia
Valeria (2 eps)
Eric Lloyd
Charlie (1 eps)
Jerry Lambert
Philip (1 eps)
Sofia Gonzalez
Marie (1 eps)
Nico Bustos
Asher (1 eps)
Peyton Manning
Peyton Manning (1 eps)
Susan Leslie
Principal Vivian (1 eps)
Waverly Corinne Meier
Jada (1 eps)
O'Neill Monahan
Teen (1 eps)
Katie O'Brien
Barista (1 eps)
David Krumholtz
Bernard (1 eps)
Jim O'Heir
Santa 17 (1 eps)
Mitch Poulos
St. Nicholas (1 eps)
Mauricio Mendoza
Papai Noel (1 eps)
Liam Seja
Young Scott (1 eps)
Dirk Rogers
Krampus (1 eps)
Teagan Johnson
Librarian (1 eps)
Neil Flynn
Donner (voice) (1 eps)
Jack McBrayer
Blitzen (voice) (1 eps)
Juan Carlos Cantu
Alfonso (1 eps)
Marcel Nahapetian
Maurice (Barber Elf) (1 eps)
Caleb Williams
Jayden (1 eps)
Oscar Daniel Reyez
Bad Guy Elf (1 eps)
Kevin Pollak
Cupid (1 eps)
Zachary Nemes
Toots (1 eps)
​Minta Fairchild Mullins
Mom (1 eps)
Tracy Morgan
The Easter Bunny (1 eps)
Paige Tamada
Proprietor (1 eps)