Tom Mison
Ichabod Crane (13 eps)
Nicole Beharie
Abbie Mills (13 eps)
Orlando Jones
Frank Irving (13 eps)
Katia Winter
Katrina Crane (13 eps)
Clancy Brown
Sheriff August Corbin (archive footage) (uncredited) (7 eps)
John Cho
Andy Brooks (6 eps)
Nicholas Gonzalez
Detective Luke Morales (6 eps)
D.J. Mifflin
Blurry Man (5 eps)
Jill Marie Jones
Cynthia Irving (4 eps)
Amandla Stenberg
Macey Irving (4 eps)
Marti Matulis
Scarecrow (3 eps)
Jeremy Owens
Headless Horseman (3 eps)
Jahneé Wallace
Young Abbie (3 eps)
Michael Roark
Devon Jones (3 eps)
David Fonteno
Priest (2 eps)
Derek Mears
Moloch (2 eps)
Patrick Gorman
Reverend Alfred Knapp (2 eps)
Christy Grantham
Front Desk Nurse (2 eps)
Onira Tarés
Grace Dixon (2 eps)
Judd Lormand
Vendor (2 eps)
Karen Beyer
Woman (2 eps)
India Scandrick
Teen Jenny (2 eps)
Richard Cetrone
Headless Horseman (Weapons) (2 eps)
Matt Mercurio
Duty Officer (2 eps)
Craig Branham
Headless Horseman (Horseback) (2 eps)
Déjá Dee
Desk Clerk (2 eps)
Nestor Serrano
Polygraph Technician (1 eps)
Charles Malik Whitfield
Parsons (1 eps)
James Frain
Rutledge (1 eps)
Tongayi Chirisa
Arthur Bernard (1 eps)
Craig Parker
Colonel Tarleton (1 eps)
Neil Jackson
Abraham Van Brunt (1 eps)
Erin Cahill
Lena Gilbert (1 eps)
Laura Spencer
Caroline (1 eps)
Carsten Norgaard
Hessian (1 eps)
Alex Collins
Thomasson (1 eps)
Tim Holt
Redcoat (1 eps)
Jackson Beals
Mason Guard (1 eps)
Parker Chapin
Crying Boy (1 eps)
Matt Medrano
Wistaron (1 eps)
Michael Teh
Seamus Duncan (1 eps)
Avis-Marie Barnes
Night Shift Nurse (1 eps)
Angela Bond
Paige Gillespie (1 eps)
Pete Burris
Garrett Gillespie (1 eps)
Kathleen York
Ms. Hudson (1 eps)
Nydia McFadden
Possessed Macey (1 eps)
Brennan Brown
Tom - Detective (1 eps)
Louis Herthum
General George Washington (1 eps)
Victor Garber
Mr. Crane (1 eps)
Chris Walters
Sleepy Hollow Officer #1 (1 eps)
Dwayne Boyd
Sleepy Hollow Officer #2 (1 eps)
Elaine Nalee
Doctor (1 eps)
Aerli Austen
Waitress (1 eps)
Michael Tourek
Prison Guard (1 eps)
Huntington Daly
Aide (1 eps)
Nat Padgett
Militiaman (1 eps)
Henry Bazemore Jr.
Officer (1 eps)
Claire Bronson
Denise Hemmington (1 eps)
Jason Davis
Jeremy Furth (1 eps)
Monique Ganderton
Serilda (1 eps)
Mary Kraft
Dr. Vega (1 eps)
David Kronawitter
Male Doctor (1 eps)
Alex Livinalli
Wiroh (1 eps)
Carl LeMon
Priest (1 eps)
David Maldonado
Derek (Fireman) (1 eps)
Michelle Rivera Huckaby
EMT (1 eps)
Roxy Olin
Burned Serilda (1 eps)
Frank Roberts
Magistrate (1 eps)
Wes Watson
Kyle (1 eps)
Kevin Cassidy
Armin (1 eps)
Phillip DeVona
Wendel Clark (1 eps)
Lars Gerhard
Hagen (1 eps)
Susan Shalhoub Larkin
Luanne Harley (1 eps)
Patrick Thomas Hogan
Colonial Soldier (1 eps)
Paul Brian Johnson
Forensic Tech (1 eps)
William Neenan
Doxford (1 eps)
Braden Fitzgerald
Jeremy (12 Years Old) (1 eps)
Danny Rawley
Jeremy (17 Years Old) (1 eps)
Katrina Despain
Isa (1 eps)
Carrie Anne Hunt
Jer (1 eps)
Arin Logan
Nahum (1 eps)
Rya Meyers
Mal (1 eps)
Joe Knezevich
Father Daniel (1 eps)
Matt Lintz
Thomas Grey (1 eps)
Miles Doleac
William Grey (1 eps)
Summer Parker
Girl (1 eps)
Dikran Tulaine
Prefect (1 eps)
Marc Fajardo
EMT (1 eps)
Vicki Ellis Gray
Mail Carrier (1 eps)
Robin Dale Robertson
Gov. John White (1 eps)
Kevin Patrick Murphy
Ananias Dare (1 eps)
Becca Potter
Eleanor Dare (1 eps)
Adora Dei
CDC Member (1 eps)
Meg Gillentine
Hazmat Doctor (1 eps)
Sophia Watson
Flower Girl (1 eps)
Joy Glover Walters
Medic (1 eps)
Danielle Sagona
Woman (1 eps)
Lance Tafelski
Hessian Soldier (1 eps)
Craig Trow
Lachlan Fredericks (1 eps)
Anthony K. Hyatt
Sam (1 eps)
Quinten Johnson
Young Butler (1 eps)
Garrett Graham
Corey Weaver (1 eps)
Craig Stark
Chase Weaver (1 eps)
Gray Hawks
Specialist (1 eps)
Jon W. Sparks
Benjamin Franklin (1 eps)
Mike Whaley
Police Officer (1 eps)
Jimmy Gonzales
Homicide Detective Nuñez (1 eps)
Garrett Kruithof
Colonial Soldier (1 eps)
Daniel J. Roberts
Tour Guide (1 eps)
Vince Pisani
Paul Short (1 eps)
Neko Parham
Fuller (1 eps)
Jayson Warner Smith
Carlton (1 eps)
Mark Jeffrey Miller
Jesse Adams (1 eps)
Stephen Shelton
Hessian (1 eps)
Kenneth Strong
Acolyte of Moloch #3 (1 eps)
Bradley Johnson
Acolyte of Moloch #4 (1 eps)
Alexander Bryant
Acolyte of Moloch #5 (1 eps)
Jim McKeny
George (1 eps)
John Curran
Oxford Professor (1 eps)
Katie Malia
Faceless Woman (1 eps)
Jason Vail
Latex Man #1 (1 eps)
Jeremy Tuttle
Latex Man #2 (1 eps)
Allen O'Reilly
Samuel Adams (1 eps)
Paul Burke
Paul Revere (1 eps)
Rae Becka
Mom (1 eps)
Zach Shirey
Son (1 eps)
Erica Page
Chat Lady (1 eps)