Janet Montgomery
Mary Sibley (36 eps)
Shane West
John Alden (36 eps)
Seth Gabel
Cotton Mather (36 eps)
Tamzin Merchant
Anne Hale (36 eps)
Ashley Madekwe
Tituba (36 eps)
Elise Eberle
Mercy Lewis (36 eps)
Iddo Goldberg
Isaac Walton (36 eps)
Oliver Bell
Little John (23 eps)
Xander Berkeley
Magistrat Hale (13 eps)
Lucy Lawless
Condessa Marburg (13 eps)
Joe Doyle
Baron Sebastian Marburg (10 eps)
Samuel Roukin
The Sentinel (8 eps)
David Shiflett
Naked Dead Body (7 eps)
Stephen Lang
Increase Mather (2 eps)
Hank Harris
Corwin (2 eps)
Ashton Smiley
Acolyte (2 eps)
Lucy Faust
Elizabeth (1 eps)
Antonia Prebble
Bridget Bishop (1 eps)
Clint James
Isaac's Man (1 eps)
Braden Fitzgerald
Stephen (1 eps)
Nadine Lewington
Rebecca Nurse (1 eps)
Lara Grice
Mrs. Hale (1 eps)
Caroline Hebert
Teenage Girl (1 eps)
Ava Ticotin
Past Countess (1 eps)