Bryan Greenberg
Nick Garrett (20 eps)
Laura Prepon
Hannah Daniels (20 eps)
Tom Berenger
The Commander (20 eps)
Warren Christie
Ray 'Big Cat' Cataldo (20 eps)
Brad William Henke
Owen Rowan (20 eps)
Evan Jones
Ikey (20 eps)
Jay Paulson
Physical Phil (20 eps)
Slade Pearce
Sam Daniels (20 eps)
Geoff Stults
Eddie Latekka (20 eps)
Odette Annable
Aubrey (20 eps)
Jonathan Murphy
Ronnie Garrett (11 eps)
Elizabeth Bogush
Alison Rowan (9 eps)
Julie Ann Emery
Christine Cataldo (3 eps)
Zach Mills
Young Nick (2 eps)
Jessica Stroup
Taylor (1 eps)
Bella Thorne
Angela Ferilli (1 eps)
Osgood Perkins
Dr. Joshua Stone (1 eps)
Joey Luthman
Young Physical Phil (as Joey Wagner Luthman) (1 eps)
Remy Thorne
Young Eddie (1 eps)
Blake Michael
Young Ronny (1 eps)
Blair Redford
Ross St. Marie (1 eps)
Lauren Gibson
Amanda Brynner (1 eps)