Jonathan Groff
Patrick Murray (18 eps)
Frankie J. Alvarez
Agustín Lanuez (18 eps)
Murray Bartlett
Dom Basaluzzo (18 eps)
Lauren Weedman
Doris (17 eps)
Raúl Castillo
Ricardo "Richie" Donado Ventura (17 eps)
Russell Tovey
Kevin Matheson (15 eps)
Andrew Law
Owen (9 eps)
O-T Fagbenle
Frank (8 eps)
Daniel Franzese
Eddie (8 eps)
Bashir Salahuddin
Malik (6 eps)
Ptolemy Slocum
Hugo (5 eps)
Joe Williamson
Jon (5 eps)
Chris Perfetti
Brady (4 eps)
TJ Linnard
CJ (3 eps)
Matthew Risch
Matthew (3 eps)
Amy York Rubin
Meredith (3 eps)
Tanner Cohen
Scotty (2 eps)
Ann Magnuson
Stina (2 eps)
Derek Ray
Ethan (2 eps)
Carlos Carrasco
Jack (2 eps)
Richard Conti
Randy (2 eps)
Kelli Garner
Megan Murray (2 eps)
Julia Duffy
Dana Murray (2 eps)
D'Lo
Taj (2 eps)
Jennifer Foster
Kyah (2 eps)
Matthew Wilkas
Benjamin (1 eps)
Andrew Keenan-Bolger
Alex (1 eps)
Kimberly Legg
Bethany (1 eps)
Brian Gattas
Faerie (1 eps)
Adrian Anchondo
Adrian (1 eps)
Jesse Garcia
Hector (1 eps)
Tanya Saracho
Ceci (1 eps)
Mary Kay Place
Aunt Sarah (1 eps)
Hayes MacArthur
Barry Foster (1 eps)
John Robinson
Liam (1 eps)
Boston Rush Freeman
Zoo Visitor (uncredited) (1 eps)
Honey Mahogany
Self (1 eps)
Jason Ralph
Jason (1 eps)
Scott Evans
Cody Heller (1 eps)
Anthony Hill
Robert (1 eps)
Jhoni Marchinko
Noelle (1 eps)
Charlyne Yi
Cashier (1 eps)
Gabe Liedman
Brent (1 eps)
Christine Estabrook
Realtor (1 eps)
Wesley Taylor
Milo (1 eps)
Sean Maher
Jake (1 eps)