Amber Tamblyn
Joan Girardi (45 eps)
Joe Mantegna
Will Girardi (45 eps)
Mary Steenburgen
Helen Girardi (45 eps)
Jason Ritter
Kevin Girardi (45 eps)
Michael Welch
Luke Girardi (45 eps)
Christopher Marquette
Adam Rove (44 eps)
Becky Wahlstrom
Grace Polk (44 eps)
Elaine Hendrix
Ms. Lischak (16 eps)
Kris Lemche
Cute Boy God (9 eps)
Sydney Tamiia Poitier
Rebecca Askew (8 eps)
John Getz
D.A. Gabe Fellowes (6 eps)
Erik Palladino
Lt. Michael Daghlian (5 eps)
Wentworth Miller
Ryan Hunter (2 eps)
Kara Zediker
Sara Bonner (1 eps)
Kat Graham
Angela (1 eps)
Laura Marano
Emily (1 eps)
Douglas Smith
Daniel Shoalar (1 eps)
Candice Azzara
Housewife God (1 eps)
Zachary Quinto
Pretentious Filmmaker God (1 eps)
Nate Dushku
Clay Fisher (1 eps)
Jan Devereaux
Lisa Van Horn (1 eps)
Jessica Szohr
Nikki (1 eps)
Michael J. Willett
Billy (1 eps)
Laura Niemi
Female customer (1 eps)
Jeremy Garrett
Todd Bainbridge (1 eps)
David Doty
Businessman God (1 eps)
Daniel Edward Mora
Deliveryman God (1 eps)
Andrew Ableson
Andy Rees (1 eps)
Barbara Evans
Jeanne (1 eps)
Andy Forrest
Shopper (1 eps)
Scott Damian
Reporter (1 eps)
Catherine Petra Villalobos
Skater Girl (uncredited) (1 eps)