Glenn Hetrick
Self - Judge (162 eps)
Michael Westmore
Self - Mentor (162 eps)
McKenzie Westmore
Self - Host (162 eps)
Neville Page
Self - Judge (162 eps)
Ve Neill
Self - Judge (162 eps)
Nix Herrera
Self - Contestant (10 eps)
Rick Baker
Guest Judge (2 eps)
Doug Jones
Guest Judge (1 eps)
Jamie Kelman
Himself (1 eps)
Mike Mekash
Himself (1 eps)
Jordu Schell
Himself (1 eps)
Todd Masters
Himself (1 eps)
John Wynn
Self (1 eps)
Eryn Krueger Mekash
Guest Judge (1 eps)
Elizabeth Mitchell
Guest Judge (1 eps)
Travis Wall
Guest Judge (1 eps)
Cheyenne Jackson
Guest Judge (1 eps)
Neil Druckmann
Guest Judge (1 eps)
John Landis
Guest Judge (1 eps)
Paul W. S. Anderson
Guest Judge (1 eps)
Suzanne Todd
Guest Judge (1 eps)
Marcus Nispel
Guest Judge (1 eps)
Lois Burwell
Guest Judge (1 eps)
John Rhys-Davies
Self - Guest Judge (1 eps)
Jim Lee
Self - Guest Judge (1 eps)
Dan Didio
Self - Guest Judge (1 eps)
Cassandra Peterson
Elvira (1 eps)