Chris Evans
Andy Barber (8 eps)
Michelle Dockery
Laurie Barber (8 eps)
Jaeden Martell
Jacob Barber (8 eps)
Cherry Jones
Joanna Klein (8 eps)
Pablo Schreiber
Neal Logiudice (8 eps)
Betty Gabriel
Pam Duffy (8 eps)
Sakina Jaffrey
Lynn Canavan (8 eps)
Daniel Henshall
Leonard Patz (8 eps)
Jordan Alexa Davis
Sarah Grohl (8 eps)
Ben Taylor
Derek Yoo (8 eps)
Megan Byrne
Joan Rifkin (5 eps)
J.K. Simmons
Billy Barber (5 eps)
Poorna Jagannathan
Elizabeth Vogel (4 eps)
Tamara Hickey
Toby (4 eps)
Patrick Fischler
Dan Rifkin (4 eps)
Hale Lytle
Matt McGrath (3 eps)
Maria Elena Ramirez
Cara (3 eps)
Ted Arcidi
Kingston (3 eps)
Liam Kilbreth
Ben Rifkin (3 eps)
Shawn Fitzgibbon
Detective Peterson (3 eps)
William Xifaras
Father O'Leary (3 eps)
Devon Diep
Reiko (3 eps)
Cheryl McMahon
Mrs. Mandel (3 eps)
Daryl Edwards
Judge French (2 eps)
Therese Plaehn
Lita McGrath (2 eps)
Myra Lucretia Taylor
Judge Rivera (2 eps)
Aaron Andrade
Mr. Fuller (2 eps)
Frankie Francois
Sienna (2 eps)
Michele Proude
Court Clerk (2 eps)
Carrie Ann Quinn
Kathleen (2 eps)
Odis Spencer
Principal (2 eps)
Marilyn Busch
Court Clerk (2 eps)
Berlis Cuevas
Bailiff (2 eps)
Shannon Ashe
Christine (1 eps)
Alfred Briere
Molloy (1 eps)
Gene Dante
Ian (1 eps)
Mai Delapa
Katie (1 eps)
Rebecca Gibel
Wendy (1 eps)
Gary Kirby
Older Man (1 eps)
Collin Knight
Police Officer (1 eps)
Ian Lyons
Burt Knox (1 eps)
Melissa McMeekin
Roxanne (1 eps)
Angela Hope Smith
Molloy's Counsel (1 eps)
Raymond Alongi
Park Ranger (1 eps)
Rebekah Curtis-Motley
Cashier (1 eps)
Michael Jibrin
Detective Freeman (1 eps)
Sarah McLean
Female Officer (1 eps)
Daniel Washington
Officer at Trailhead (1 eps)
Sam Zephir
Officer #1 (1 eps)
Tom Mariano
Walpole Prison Guard (1 eps)
Tobias Wilson
CPAC Trooper (1 eps)
Phoenix Curcuru
Phoebe (1 eps)
Audrey Wasilewski
Jeanine (1 eps)
Caralyn Aufiero
Waitress (1 eps)
Evan Risser
6-Year-Old Andy (1 eps)
Kallie Tabor
Kirsten (1 eps)
Lizzie Short
Andy's Mom (1 eps)
Austin J. Ryan
Lacrosse Kid (1 eps)
Hannah Yun
Dina Yoo (1 eps)
Mariko Kanto
Waitress (1 eps)
Jim Boyd
Reporter at Courthouse (1 eps)
Ken Cheeseman
Rod Renborg (1 eps)
Rena Maliszewski
Karen Carlson (1 eps)
Damon Singletary
Bartender (1 eps)
Michael Tow
Reporter (1 eps)
Michelle Violette
Paula Gianetto (1 eps)
Stephanie Bisono
Nurse (1 eps)
Jessi Case
Hope Connors (1 eps)
Chelsea Hueter
Reporter (1 eps)