Phil Nobile Jr.
Self - Editor in Chief, Fangoria (5 eps)
Mitch Horowitz
Himself - Author, Occult America (4 eps)
Ryan Turek
Self (3 eps)
Hector Avalos
Himself - Professor of Religious Studies (2 eps)
Doug Cowan
Himself - Professor of Religious Studies (2 eps)
Vincent Bauhaus
Himself - Exorcist (1 eps)
Linda Blair
Herself - Actor (1 eps)
Eileen Dietz
Herself - Actor (1 eps)
Arturo David Rodríguez González
Himself (1 eps)
Sarah Graff
Herself - Associate Curator, The Metropolitan Museum of Art (1 eps)
Barton Lane
Himself - Radiologist (1 eps)
Matt Miller
Himself - Journalist, Esquire (1 eps)
Victoria Helen Mosha
Herself (1 eps)
Nestor Vincent-Pomales
Himself (1 eps)
April Wolfe
Herself - Film Critic (1 eps)
Ciara Antoski
Herself (1 eps)
Samuel Archer
Himself (1 eps)
Nate Bales
Himself - Black Magician, Four Thrones (1 eps)
Alaana Bergin
Herself (1 eps)
Tony Burke
Himself - Professor of Religious Studies (1 eps)
Michael Correll
Himself - Witch (1 eps)
Richard Donner
Himself - Director, The Omen (1 eps)
Andres Galindo
Himself (1 eps)
Matt Gourley
Himself - Podcaster (1 eps)
Brandon P. Hayes
Himself (1 eps)
Matthew Hutson
Himself - Author, The 7 Laws of Magical Thinking (1 eps)
E.A. Koetting
Himself - Black Magician (1 eps)
Afolabi Kolawole
Himself (1 eps)
Lyubov Lyutenko
Himself (1 eps)
Adrian Martin
Himself (1 eps)
Joseph Mazur
Himself - Author, Fluke: The Math and Myth of Coincidence (1 eps)
Viktoriya Moskalyuk
Herself (1 eps)
Mace Neufeld
Himself - Executive Producer, The Omen (1 eps)
Luis Prasad-Bernier
Himself (1 eps)
Clay Routledge
Himself - Professor of Psychology (1 eps)
Dr. Michael Shermer
Himself - Publisher, Skeptic Magazine (1 eps)
Roger Deakins
Self (1 eps)
Krishan Thapar
Himself (1 eps)
Ruggero Deodato
Self (1 eps)
Francesca Ciardi
Self (1 eps)
Luca Barbareschi
Self (1 eps)
Carl Gabriel Yorke
Self (1 eps)
Massimo Antonello Geleng
Self (1 eps)
Sergio D'Offizi
Self (1 eps)
Eduardo Sánchez
Self (1 eps)
Nick Pinkerton
Self (1 eps)