Kiernan Shipka
Sabrina Spellman (16 eps)
Ross Lynch
Harvey Kinkle (16 eps)
Lucy Davis
Hilda Spellman (16 eps)
Miranda Otto
Zelda Spellman (16 eps)
Chance Perdomo
Ambrose Spellman (16 eps)
Michelle Gomez
Mary Wardwell (16 eps)
Jaz Sinclair
Rosalind Walker (16 eps)
Richard Coyle
Father Blackwood (16 eps)
Tati Gabrielle
Prudence Night (16 eps)
Adeline Rudolph
Agatha (16 eps)
Gavin Leatherwood
Nick Scratch (16 eps)
Lachlan Watson
Theo Putnam (16 eps)
Tyler Cotton
Melvin (3 eps)
Luke Cook
Lucifer Morningstar (2 eps)
Sam Corlett
Caliban (2 eps)
Oliver Rice
Lazarus (2 eps)
Beth Broderick
Zelda Spellman (1 eps)
Caroline Rhea
Hilda Spellman (1 eps)
Em Haine
Elspeth (1 eps)
Chris Walters
Matt (1 eps)
Meaghan Chenosky
Donna (1 eps)
Jonathan Whitesell
Robin Goodfellow (1 eps)
James Urbaniak
The Trinket Man (1 eps)
Xantha Radley
Mrs. Meeks (1 eps)
Darius Willis
Judas (1 eps)
Whitney Peak
Judith (1 eps)
Melody Nosipho Niemann
Trick-or-Treat Witch (1 eps)
Billy Christos Jr.
Trick-or-Treat Kid #2 (1 eps)
Connor O'Mahony
Trick-or-Treat Kid #3 (1 eps)
Christopher Rosamond
Mr. Kinkle (1 eps)
Nelson Leis
Beelzebub (1 eps)
Ron Selmour
Baron Samedi (1 eps)
Nathalie Boltt
Ms. Dubois (1 eps)
Daniel Nemes
Pontius Pilate (1 eps)
Spencer Lang
Strong Man #2 (1 eps)
Max Moore
Young Boy (1 eps)