Laura Linney
Samantha Prescott
Mark Ruffalo
Terry Prescott
Matthew Broderick
Brian Everett
Jon Tenney
Bob Steegerson
Rory Culkin
Rudy Prescott
Halley Feiffer
Amy
J. Smith-Cameron
Mabel
Josh Lucas
Rudy (Kolinski) Sr.
Gaby Hoffmann
Sheila
Amy Ryan
Rachel Louise Prescott
Adam LeFevre
Sheriff Darryl
Kenneth Lonergan
Ron
Nina Garbiras
Nancy Everett
Kim Parker
Rudy Sr.'s Girlfriend
Michael Countryman
Thomas Gerard Prescott
Whitney Vance
Young Sammy Prescott
Peter Kerwin
Young Terry Prescott
Betsy Aidem
Minister
Lisa Altomare
Waitress
Richard Hummer
Plumber
Allan Gill
Older Cop
Brian Ramage
Young Cop