Ben Johnson
Travis Blue
Joanne Dru
Denver
Harry Carey, Jr.
Sandy
Ward Bond
Elder Wiggs
Charles Kemper
Uncle Shiloh Clegg
Alan Mowbray
Dr. A. Locksley Hall
Jane Darwell
Sister Ledyard
Ruth Clifford
Fleuretty Phyffe
Russell Simpson
Adam Perkins
Kathleen O'Malley
Prudence Perkins
James Arness
Floyd Clegg
Francis Ford
Mr. Peachtree
Fred Libby
Reese Clegg
Jim Thorpe
Navajo Indian
Mickey Simpson
Jesse Clegg
Cliff Lyons
Marshal of Crystal City
Don Summers
Sam Jenkins
Movita
Young Navajo Indian
Hank Worden
Luke Clegg
Chuck Hayward
Jackson (uncredited)
Danny Borzage
Accordionist (uncredited)
Lee Bradley
Leader of the Navajo Band (uncredited)
Nora Bush
Settler (uncredited)
Jane Crowley
Settler (uncredited)
Tex Holden
Settler (uncredited)
George Huggins
Settler (uncredited)
Fred Kennedy
Settler (uncredited)
Al Kunde
Fiddler (uncredited)
Ann Kunde
Settler (uncredited)
Frank McGrath
Posse Member (uncredited)
Evelyn Moriarty
Settler (uncredited)
Eleanore Vogel
Settler (uncredited)