Ellie Kemper
Pam McKenzie
Rob Delaney
Jeff McKenzie
Archie Yates
Max Mercer
Aisling Bea
Carol Mercer
Pete Holmes
Uncle Blake
Kenan Thompson
Gavin Washington
Timothy Simons
Hunter
Ally Maki
Mei
Chris Parnell
Uncle Stu
Devin Ratray
Buzz McCallister
Katie Beth Hall
Abby McKenzie
Max Ivutin
Chris McKenzie
Andy Daly
Mike Mercer
Madeline Holliday
Katie Mercer
Mikey Day
Priest
Jordan Carlos
Clem Breckin
Esther Povitsky
Daisy Breckin
Marty Adams
Annoying Passenger
Jim Rash
Bell Choir Leader
Catherine Cohen
Mrs. Claus
Amy Okuda
Ticketing Agent
Bronwen Mantel
Barbara
Peter Schoelier
Herman
Tristan D. Lalla
Orderly
Nancy Helms
Enthusiastic Orderly
Gayle Garfinkle
Old Lady Coven
Jane Gilchrist
Old Lady Coven
Hazel Gorin
Old Lady Coven
Cara Ricketts
Aunt Beth
Aiden Wang
Ollie
Allan Wang
Ollie
Amadeo Correia
Young Chris McKenzie
Aron Benali
Ryan
Emilio Williams
Stu's Child #1
Sylvia Simonetti
Stu's Child #2
Osias Reid
Burke Son #1
Dylan Eugene Olivier
Burke Son #2
Deryk Eugene Olivier
Burke Son #3