Fiona Palomo
Mary
Milo Manheim
Joseph of Nazareth
Antonio Banderas
King Herod Antipas of Judea
Joel Smallbone
General Antipater
Stephanie Gil
Rebekah
Moriah Peters
Deborah
Rizwan Manji
Gaspar
Omid Djalili
Melchior
Geno Segers
Balthazar
Lecrae
Archangel Gabriel
Antonio Gil
Jacob
Alicia Borrachero
Rachel
María Pau Pigem
Ana
Pedro Aijón
Lieutenant
Ricard Serra
Census Taker
Juan José Marco
Unhappy Man
Eric Halverson
Healer
Juan Jesús Di Manuel
Prisoner
Daniela Riveri
Magi's Servant Girl