Daniel Zolghadri
Robert
Matthew Maher
Wallace
Miles Emanuel
Miles
Maria Dizzia
Jennifer
Josh Pais
Lewis
Stephen Adly Guirgis
Mr. Katano
Marcia DeBonis
Cheryl
Michael Townsend Wright
Barry
Cleveland Thomas Jr
Steven
Rob M. Anderson
Comic Shop Clerk
Ron Rifkin
Grandfather
Tony Hassini
Richard
Andy Milonakis
George
Mitchell Wenig
Jared
Sylvia Michael Martinez
Pharmacist
Shane Fleming
Gabe
Peter Lucibello
Santa
Constance Shulman
Mrs. Ochs
Charlie Judkins
Comics Expert
Robert Cribbie
Funeral Speaker
Randy Costanza
Funeral Speaker 2
Pamela Dunlap
Judge
Devon Reiff
The Family Lawyer
Michael Quinn
Pharmacy Punk
Tyrone Mitchell Henderson
District Attorney
Michael Citriniti
Pharmacy Customer
Buddy Duress
Ryan
Gore Jones
Card Player
Michael DiBartola
Card Wizard
Jedediah Joseph Smith
Janitor
Louise Lasser
Linda (Pharmacy Lady)
Lawrence S. O'Connell
Comedian (uncredited)
Charlie Chaspooley Robinson
Gas Station Attendant (uncredited)