Jonah Hill
Michael Finkel
James Franco
Christian Longo
Felicity Jones
Jill Barker
Maria Dizzia
Mary Jane Longo
Ethan Suplee
Pat Frato
Robert John Burke
Greg Ganley
Charlotte Driscoll
Sadie Longo
Kohl Sudduth
Police Officer
Conor Kikot
Zach Longo
Stella Rae Payne
Madison Longo
Byron Jennings
Judge Odenkirk
Gretchen Mol
Karen
Betty Gilpin
Cheryl
Seth Barrish
Blaise
Robert Stanton
Jeffrey Gregg
Michael Countryman
Coroner
Steve Routman
Jack Pool
Genevieve Angelson
Tina Alvis
Adam Mucci
Courtroom Sheriff
David Wilson Barnes
Corey Douglas
William Jackson Harper
Zak Rausch
Sam Rosen
Steve Mensah
Mara Hobel
Jail Receptionist
David Pittu
Marcus Lickermann
Auden Thornton
Lena
Ngo Okafor
Ibrahim
Uchenna Onuaguluchi
Madou
Maryann Plunkett
Maureen Duffy
Joseph Harrell
Visiting Room Guard #1
Mike Houston
Visiting Room Guard #2
Rosemary Howard
Jury Forewoman
Joel Marsh Garland
Dan Pegg
Dana Eskelson
Joy Longo
Peter Francis James
Colin Parker
Edward James Hyland
Mr. Longo
Johanna Day
Beth Tickler
Georgia Ford
Young Woman
Loudon Wainwright III
Older Man
Julie Sharbutt
Female MSU Worker
Eleanor Hutchins
Middle-Aged Woman
Rebecca Henderson
Ellen Parks
Jay Ferraro
Geoffrey J. Ploobtark
Bill Walters
Inmate (uncredited)