Dwayne Johnson
Derek Thompson / Tooth Fairy
Stephen Merchant
Tracy
Ashley Judd
Carly
Julie Andrews
Lily
Ryan Sheckler
Mick Donnelly
Seth MacFarlane
Ziggy
Destiny Whitlock
Tess
Chase Ellison
Randy
Darien Provost
Gabe
Alex Ferris
Shelter Cove Kid
Nicole Muñoz
Kelly
Brendan Meyer
Ben
Josh Emerson
Kyle
Brandon T. Jackson
Duke
Dan Joffre
Tooth Fairy #1
Ellie Harvie
Permit Woman
Barclay Hope
Coach
Michael Daingerfield
Announcer
Dale Wolfe
Color Commentator
Anthony Bewlz
Brad
Brendan Penny
Josh
Lee Tichon
Andreas
Jill Morrison
Shelter Cove Mom
Rukiya Bernard
Amnesia Woman
Maya Washington
Amnesia Daughter
Daniel Bacon
Fan
Christina Schild
Poltergeist Woman
Nicholas Carella
Poltergeist Man
Derek Gilroy
Crazed Fan
Brendan Beiser
Teddy's Dad
Fiona Hogan
Scared Woman
Peter Kelamis
Talent Show Teacher
Steve Levy
Himself
Candus Churchill
Amnesia Grandma
David Quinlan
Gabe's Dad
John Tench
Inmate
Ron Toffolo
Sports Reporter
Stephen Holmes
Shelter Cove Dad
Billy Crystal
Jerry (uncredited)