Danielle Panabaker
Katie Lapp
Sherry Stringfield
Laura Mayfield-Bennett
Sarah Maine
Jessica
Willie Stratford
Theodore
Jason Loughlin
Benjamin Lapp
Sandra Elise Williams
Rebecca Lapp
Bill Oberst Jr.
Samuel Lapp
Wyatt Lanier
Jacob Beiler
Burgess Jenkins
Bishop John Beiler
Dalton Parrish
Hickory John Beiler
David Topp
Daniel Fisher
Richard Fullerton
Ephram Yoder
Nancy Saunders
Ella Mae Zook
Rachel St. Gelais
Benjamin's Daughter
Jana Allen
Amanda
Sarah E. Chambers
Mary Stoltzfus
Michele Lee
Store Clerk
Jimmy Hager
Preacher Yoder
David Forrester
Amish Elder
Scott Helms
Amish Man
Robert C. Treveiler
Surgeon
Stephen West-Rogers
Trauma Nurse
Lee Freeman
Nurse Rosie
Alexa Yeames
Young Laura
Tim Holt
Dylan Bennett
Lindsey Moser
Nurse (uncredited)