Melissa Joan Hart
Rose DeMarco
Jaleel White
Paul Greenberg
Barry Watson
Nick DeMarco
Melissa Sagemiller
Carol Guthrie
Scott Grimes
John Guthrie
Wendy Williams
Pastor Ruth
Tucker Meek
Billy Guthrie
Alimi Ballard
Steve Repperton
John Ratzenberger
Warden Jeffrey Mitchell
Matthew Porter
Walter Banfield
P.J. Marino
Foreman
Dior Raye
Olivia
Andrea Cirie
Mrs. Stanwyck
Lucy DeVito
June
Michael Patrick Lane
Bartender
Brian J. Carter
Ernie
Matthew F. O'Connor
Phil
Bonnie Discepolo
Woman in Bar
Cameron Meyer
Chairwoman
Jonathan Savage
Jerky Kid
Kairo Chelani Ballard
Little Boy 1
Braydon Wilkerson
Little Boy 2
Christopher Savage
Little Boy 3
Charlie Santoyo
Little Boy 4
Mason Lahd Wilkerson
Little Boy 5
Olivia Bell-Cross
Little Girl 1
Destiny Figueroa
Little Girl 2
Naya Seray Ballard
Little Girl 3
Mitch Longley
Mr. Waxman
Enrique Menéndez
Parole Board Member
Brian Hart
Police Officer
Becky Baker
Young Mother
Joseph Basile
Contractor (uncredited)
Erik Bloomquist
Policeman (uncredited)
Elizabeth Hart
Elf (uncredited)
Mackenzie Lee Hart
Elf (uncredited)
William Hart
Poker Player (uncredited)
Jamie Leo
Extra (uncredited)
Hudson Meek
Wiseman (uncredited)
Mark Wilkerson
Sentry (uncredited)
Tucker Wilkerson
Little Boy on Santa's Lap (uncredited)