Burt Reynolds
Narrator (voice)
Bill Fagerbakke
Frosty the Snowman (voice)
Larry Miller
Principal Pankley (voice)
Grey DeLisle
Miss Sharpey / Simon Sklarow / Sullivan Sklarow (voice)
Jeannie Elias
Charlie Tinkerton / Librarian (voice)
Evan Gore
Paperboy (voice)
David Jeremiah
Mr. Simple / Townsperson #1 / Mr. Sklarow (voice)
Tom Kenny
Mr. Tinkerton (voice)
Tress MacNeille
Mrs. Simple / Girl #1 (voice)
Candi Milo
Mrs. Tinkerton / Girl #2 (voice)
Kath Soucie
Tommy Tinkerton / Old Sara Simple (voice)
Tara Strong
Sara Simple / Sonny Sklarow (voice)
Kenn Michael
Walter Wader (voice)