Vanessa Hudgens
Brooke
Josh Whitehouse
Sir Cole Christopher Frederick Lyons of Norwich
Emmanuelle Chriqui
Madison
Harry Jarvis
Sir Geoffrey
Ella Kenion
Old Crone
Isabelle Franca
Claire
Mimi Gianopulos
Alyson
Jean-Michel Le Gal
David
Arnold Pinnock
Officer Stevens
Scott Ryan Yamamura
Evan
Jayne Eastwood
Eileen
Shanice Johnson
Paige
Scott Edgecombe
Santa Claus
Kristin Shepherd
Mrs Claus
Neil Babcock
James - Brooke's Ex
Olivia Gudaniec
Kaelynn - James' Girlfriend
Alex Armbruster
Young Husband at Tree Farm
Brittany Rae Robinson
Young Wife at Tree Farm
Andrea Senior
Christmas Caroler #2
Hayley Festeryga
Teenage Girl
Jacob Soley
Patrick (uncredited)
Rob Lowe
Derek
Kristin Davis
Kate (archive footage)
Chris Hobbs
Knight
Simon Webster
Reed
Kat Graham
Abby Sutton (archive footage)
Quincy Brown
Josh Barton (archive footage)