Robert Downey Jr.
Hank Palmer
Robert Duvall
Joseph Palmer
Vera Farmiga
Samantha Powell
Vincent D'Onofrio
Glen Palmer
Jeremy Strong
Dale Palmer
Dax Shepard
C.P. Kennedy
Billy Bob Thornton
Dwight Dickham
Leighton Meester
Carla Powell
Ken Howard
Judge Warren
Emma Tremblay
Lauren Palmer
Balthazar Getty
Deputy Hanson
David Krumholtz
Mike Kattan
Grace Zabriskie
Mrs. Blackwell
Denis O'Hare
Doc Morris
Sarah Lancaster
Lisa Palmer
Lonnie Farmer
Gus the Bailiff
Matt Riedy
Sheriff White
Mark Kiely
Mark Blackwell
Jeremy Holm
Redneck
Catherine Cummings
Mary Palmer
Tamara Hickey
Amy Palmer
Paul Emile
Joe Palmer
Ian Nelson
Eric Palmer
Carol S. Austin
Young Mary Palmer
Marcus D'Angelo
Dale (10)
Michael Celata
Hank (5)
Bobby Bryan
Hank (16)
Cody Pettola
Glen (5)
Johnny Orlando
Glen (17)
Gary Wayne Farris
Judge (39)
Ras Enoch McCurdie
Mini Mart Clerk
Ian Blackman
Mr. Burke
John Talalas
Chicago Sheriff Deputy
Daryl Edwards
Judge Carter
Joel Brady
Mr. Williams
Sara Jane Burns
Pregnant Ex
Ara Glenn-Johanson
Potential Juror #5
Kate Crowley
Potential Juror #9
Peter Michael McDonald
Juror #3
Michael Patrick Kane
Juror #7
Lance Norris
Juror #8
Lenny Clarke
Juror #10
Frank Ridley
Jury Foreman
Duncan B. Putney
Dr. Putney
Pun Bandhu
Forensic Scientist
Jamison Haase
Dr. Brannamon
Lucien Spelman
Bartender Billy
Timothy John Smith
Both Ways Bobby
Jonathan Ziese
Blackwell's Brother
Brian McGrail
Townie
Joyce Greenleaf
Mourner
Enn Reitel
Mourner
Tiffany Crosby
Airport Pedestrian
Mary Hronicek
Courtroom Spectator
Susan Garfield
Flight Attendant