Juno Temple
Alice
Michael Angarano
John
Alexis Bledel
Payton
Billy Magnussen
Arnie
Alia Shawkat
Louise
Bobby Moynihan
Chuck
Steve Park
Dr. Ling
Ben Rappaport
Ricky
Lucy Walters
Mary
Jack McBrayer
Joe
Debra Monk
Trudy
Michael Delaney
Mr. Tutor
Tara Copeland
Mrs. Tutor
Thomas Middleditch
Gilad
Bob McClure
Yoel
Rebecca Darke
Mollia
Ian Scott McGregor
Interviewer
Travis Myers
Bartender
Matt Walsh
Antique Dealer
Danielle Kotch
Eight Year Old
M.K. Walsh
Female Reporter
Claudia Mason
Donna
Cristin Milioti
Brandi
Roland J. Walton
BMW Dealer
Christopher Maggi
Antiques Roadshow Attendee 1
Matthew Backer
Antiques Roadshow Attendee 2
Yuen Byun
Waxer
Adam Files
Mr. Tutor's Lover
Kirk Roos
Highway Patrolman
Christopher Jon Gombos
Cowboy (uncredited)
William Todd Levinson
Reception Attendee (uncredited)
Harry L. Seddon
Antique Collector (uncredited)