Sabrina Kern
Mary / Agatha
Carolyn Hennesy
Mother Superior
Courtney Halverson
Catherine
Seth Michaels
Father Andrew
Trin Miller
Paula
Lindsay Seim
Doris
Jayson Warner Smith
Mary's Dad
Hannah Fierman
Sarah
Shaun Fletcher
Deputy Pearl
Maximus Murrah
William
Marsha Fee Berger
Sister Susan
Rachael Gavrielli
Veronica
Myles Cranford
Doctor
Marion Guyot
Mrs. Wright
Bobby C. King
Strange Man
Marilyn Light
Sister Olga
Justin Miles
Jimmy
Wanda Morganstern
Wealthy Woman
John Penick
Mr. Wright
Candy Rachor
Sister Helen
Sara Sometti Michaels
Mary's Aunt
John Archer Lundgren
Homeless Soup Kitchen Patron (uncredited)
Tweed Michael Manning
Card Dealer (uncredited)
Geoffrey Gould
Doctor (uncredited)