Tyrone Power
Benjamin Blake
Gene Tierney
Eve
George Sanders
Sir Arthur Blake
Frances Farmer
Isabel
Elsa Lanchester
Bristol Isabel
Roddy McDowall
Benjamin - as a Boy
John Carradine
Caleb Green
Harry Davenport
Amos Kidder
Kay Johnson
Helena
Dudley Digges
Pratt
Halliwell Hobbes
Purdy
Marten Lamont
Kenneth Hobart
Arthur Hohl
Captain Greenough
Pedro de Cordoba
Feenou
Heather Thatcher
Maggie Martin
Mala
Marnoa
Lester Matthews
Prosecutor
Charles Irwin
Captain
Dennis Hoey
Lord Tarrant
Robert Greig
Judge
Clifford Severn
Paddy
Mae Marsh
Mrs. Purdy (uncredited)
Harry Cording
Turnkey (uncredited)
David Clyde
Shellback (uncredited)
Cyril McLaglen
Grimes (uncredited)
Matthew Boulton
Jury Foreman (uncredited)
Leonard Carey
Pale Tom (uncredited)
James Craven
Guard (uncredited)
Ethel Griffies
Matron (uncredited)
Olaf Hytten
Court Clerk (uncredited)
Keith Hitchcock
Crier (uncredited)
Rodd Redwing
Native (uncredited)