Lilyan Chauvin
Mother Superior
Gilmer McCormick
Sister Margaret
Toni Nero
Pamela
Robert Brian Wilson
Billy at 18
Charles Dierkop
Killer Santa
Linnea Quigley
Denise
Randy Stumpf
Andy
Britt Leach
Mr. Sims
Tara Buckman
Mother (Ellie)
Will Hare
Grandpa
Leo Geter
Tommy
Geoff Hansen
Father (Jim)
Eric Hart
Mr. Levitt (Storekeeper)
A. Madeline Smith
Sister Ellen
H.E.D. Redford
Captain Richards
Danny Wagner
Billy at 8
Jonathan Best
Billy at 5
Amy Styvesant
Cindy
Max Robinson
Officer Barnes
Nancy Borgenicht
Mrs. Randall
Vinc Massa
Young Boy Sledding: Doug
John Michael Alvarez
Young Boy Sledding: Jim
John Bishop
Older Boy Sledding: Bob
Richard C. Terry
Older Boy Sledding: Mac
Oscar Rowland
Dr. Conway
Richard D. Clark
Officer Miller
Tip Boxell
Officer Murphy
Angela Montoya
Girl on Santa's Lap
Molly Cameron
Girl's Mother
Jayne Luke
Other Mother in Store
Joan Forster
Other Mother in Store
Betsy Nagel
Other Mother in Store
Barbara Stafford
Teen Lover at Orphanage
Paul Mulder
Teen Lover at Orphanage
Spencer Ashby
Santa at Orphanage
J. Paul Broadhead
Santa in Store
Alex Burton
Brother (Ricky) at 14
Max Broadhead
Brother (Ricky) at 4
Melissa Best
Infant Ricky
Dan Rogers
Dispatcher
Spencer Alston
Child at Orphanage
Kristi Ballard
Child at Orphanage
Jacob Peterson
Child at Orphanage
Jonathan Wilde
Child at Orphanage
Susie Massa
Child at Orphanage
Sarah Stuyvesant
Child at Orphanage