Jeffrey Dean Morgan
Gerry Fenn
Cricket Brown
Alice
William Sadler
Father Hagan
Katie Aselton
Natalie Gates
Cary Elwes
Bishop Gyles
Diogo Morgado
Delgarde
Bates Wilder
Geary
Marina Mazepa
Mary of Elnor
Christine Adams
Monica Slade
Dustin Tucker
Dan Walsh
Gisela Chipe
Sophia Walsh
Danny Corbo
Toby Walsh
Sonny Corbo
Toby Walsh
Michael Strauss
Max
Madison LaPlante
Faithful Teen Girl
Doria Bramante
Waitress
Stephen O'Neil Martin
Atheist Man
Tim Estiloz
Correspondent
Ted Wayman
Correspondent
Andrea Athanassiou
Internet Woman
Hannah Jane Doyon
Internet Woman
Celeste Oliva
Librarian
Chris Byers
Shopkeeper
Mere Davis
Faithful #1
Dave Heard
Faithful #2
Kiara Pichardo
Faithful #3
Kevin Fennessy
Faithful #4
Charlie Thurston
Nervous Man Leaving Town
Mike Wendt
Blacksmith
Lisa Gresci
Journalist
Bill Thorpe
Father Prescott
Lorna Larkin
Mary Elnor (voice)
Cassidy Neal
Grace Father (uncredited)
Rob Lévesque
City Official (uncredited)
J.J. Wright
Talk Show Host (uncredited)
Adrian M. Mompoint
Camera Crew (uncredited)
Jonathan Neves
Church Goer (uncredited)
Nicholas Trotto
Church Member (uncredited)