Elisabeth Moss
Shirley Jackson
Odessa Young
Rose Nemser / Paula
Michael Stuhlbarg
Stanley Hyman
Logan Lerman
Fred Nemser
Victoria Pedretti
Katherine
Robert Wuhl
Randy Fisher
Paul O'Brien
Dean
Orlagh Cassidy
Caroline
Bisserat Tseggai
Peggy
Allen McCullough
Norman
Tony Manna
Drunken Fellow
Molly Fahey
Faculty Wife
Edward O'Blenis
Ralph Ellison
Ryan Spahn
Drunk Cad
Emily Decker
Prissy College Girl
Alexandria Sherman
Paula
Ava Langford
Rose's Friend
Thomas Racek
Party Guest
Lexa Hayes
Party Goer
Adelind Horan
Paula Double (uncredited)
Steve Vinovich
Henry (uncredited)