Newlywed bakery owner Hannah Swensen returns from her romantic cruise to a murder mystery in Lake Eden, Minnesota. Eager to settle into married life, her plans are upended when her mother’s neighbor, former stage actress Victoria Bascomb, is found murdered. With a host of enemies and suspects, Hannah must unravel the truth behind the crime while facing challenges of her own. Solving the case and surviving it might be even harder than perfecting her famous banana cream pie.