Allison Williams
Peter Pan
Christopher Walken
Captain Hook
Christian Borle
George Darling / Smee
Kelli O'Hara
Mrs. Darling
Taylor Louderman
Wendy Darling
Minnie Driver
Adult Wendy Darling / Narrator
Jake Lucas
John Darling
John Allyn
Michael Darling
Alanna Saunders
Tiger Lily
Caitlin Houlahan
Jane Darling
Jason Gotay
Tootles
Alan H. Green
Cookson
Jacob Guzman
Twin 1
David Guzman
Twin 2
F. Michael Haynie
Slightly
Austin Lesch
Bill Jukes
Chris McCarrell
Nibs
Michael Park
Cecco
Bryce Ryness
Starkey
Chris Sullivan
Noodler
Ryan Andes
Admiral Crichton
Dyllón Burnside
Prickles
John Arthur Greene
Robert Mullins / Islander
Michael Hartung
Sniffler
Garett Hawe
Patches
Dominique Kelley
Ensemble
Marty Lawson
Ensemble
Gary Milner
The Vicar / Islander
Michael Munday
Ensemble
Andrew Pirozzi
Ensemble
Daniel Quadrino
Bunting
T. Oliver Reid
Oliver Shreeks / Islander
C. J. Tyson
Ensemble
Matt Wall
Skylights / Islander
Keenan D. Washington
Ensemble
Charlie Williams
Ensemble
Alex Wong
Ensemble
Helen Anker
Dancer / Chorus
Stephanie Kim
Dancer / Chorus
Sarah O'Gleby
Dancer / Chorus
Kathryn Terza
Mermaid / understudy Tiger Lily
James Brown III
Islander / Pirate
Henry Gottfried
understudy Peter Pan/swing for lost boys