Meredith Thomas
Sheriff Hudson
Jill Awbrey
The Woman
Bill Moseley
The Caller (segment "Nite Flirt")
Sheila Ball
Myra Wright (segment "Nite Flirt")
Stephon Strickland
Ray (segment "You Promised")
Moriah N. Boone
Carol (segment "You Promised")
Jenna Kanell
Lila Cameron (segment "Miniature")
Philip Estrin
Winston
Joseph "Jojo" Martinez
The Boy (segment "We All Scream")
Amber Medina
The Mom (segment "We All Scream")
Mr. Sweetie
Himself (segment "We All Scream")
Gigi Gustin
Marion (segment "Miniature")
Peter Xifo
Janitor (segment "Miniature")
Amber Pauline
Toy (segment "Miniature")
Dan Swaney
Toy (segment "Miniature")
Or Mussman
Toy (segment "Miniature")
Jeff Kongs
Toy (segment "Miniature")
Nicholas Adams
Toy (segment "Miniature")
Collin Carter
Toy (segment "Miniature")
Nick Meyer
Toy (segment "Miniature")
Matthew Hersh
Officer Mooney (segment "You Promised")
Nick Nicholson
Jim (segment "You Promised")
Justin Miles
Will (segment "You Promised")
Jessie Allen Hitner
Rob (segment "You Promised")
Allison Victoria-Wolfe
Officer Scully (segment "You Promised")
Tara Price
Officer Starling (segment "You Promised")