Tom Hulce
Mickey Schwerner
Jennifer Grey
Rita Schwerner
Blair Underwood
James Chaney
CCH Pounder
Fannie Lee Chaney
Andre Braugher
Dennis
Josh Charles
Andrew Goodman
Walton Goggins
Lyle
Greg Kinnear
News reporter
John Dennis Johnston
Hatchet-Faced Man
Royce D. Applegate
Deputy Winter
Harry Caesar
Hollis Watkins
Scott Lawrence
Matt Suarez
Eugene Byrd
Ben Jr.
Jill Jane Clements
Ida Flowers
Thom Gossom Jr.
Charlie Parham (as Thom Gossom)
Bill Coates
Rev. Jenkins
Ted Manson
Wilbur Combs
Tanzia Franks
Barbara Chaney