Dustin Hoffman
Ben Floss
Susan Sarandon
Jojo Floss
Jake Gyllenhaal
Joe Nast
Alexia Landeau
Cheryl
Ellen Pompeo
Bertie Knox
Richard Messing
Rabbi
Lev Friedman
Cantor
Bob Clendenin
Server #1
Jim Fyfe
Server #2
Mary Ellen Trainor
Mrs. Meyerson
Richard Fancy
Mr. Meyerson
Marcia Mitzman Gaven
Fashion Plate
Holly Hunter
Mona Camp
Gordon Clapp
Tanner
Dabney Coleman
Mike Mulcahey
Allan Corduner
Stan Michaels
Careena Melia
Diana Floss
Gary Hetzler
Speedwalker
Mary Catherine Garrison
Caroline
Audrey Marie Anderson
Audrey Anders
Virginia Newcomb
Cheryl's Friend #2
Elizabeth Janas
Cheryl's Friend #3
Dee Nelson
Waitress
McNally Sagal
Mrs. Tippet
Roxanne Hart
June Mulcahey
Lisa Anne Hillman
Jillian Mulcahey
Rachel Singer
Rhonda Ketch
Alexandra Hoffman
Diner Granddaughter
Lenny Clarke
Gordy
Robert Wahlberg
Pinky
Tom Carey
Baxter
Phil Reeves
Mr. Don Tippet
John Balma
Walter Ketch
Tom Dahlgren
Judge
Mark Lotito
Diner Manager
Caitlin McKenna
Bar Voice (voice)
Jessica Gee-George
Bar Voice (voice)
Paul Pape
Bar Voice (voice)
Jillian Armenante
Caterer (uncredited)
David Wheeler
Diner Grandfather