Olivia Cooke
Rachel Kushner
Thomas Mann
Greg Gaines
RJ Cyler
Earl Jackson
Connie Britton
Greg's Mom
Nick Offerman
Greg's Dad
Molly Shannon
Denise Kushner
Jon Bernthal
Mr. McCarthy
Chelsea Zhang
Naomi
Masam Holden
Ill Phil
Katherine Hughes
Madison
Matt Bennett
Scott Mayhew
Bobb'e J. Thompson
Derrick
Gavin Dietz
Young Greg
Edward DeBruce III
Young Earl
Natalie Marchelletta
Anna
Marco Zappala
Theater Dork
Kaza Marie Ayersman
Rachel's Friend
Etta Cox
Principal
Karriem Sami
Limo Driver
Hugh Jackman
Hugh Jackman (voice)
Cheryl Kline
Rabbi
Joan Augustin
Elderly Mourner
Mark Granatire
Testimonial Student #1
Kayana White
Testimonial Student #2
Linda Kanyarusoke
Testimonial Student #3
Drew Palajsa
Testimonial Student #4
Elly Silberstein
Testimonial Student #5
Nicole Tubbs
Children's Hospital Nurse
Joe Fishel
Shiva Attendee (uncredited)
Jeremy Long
Theater Student (uncredited)
Zander Lyons
High School Student (uncredited)
Jake Scheib
Friend (uncredited)
Jackson Nunn
School Teacher (uncredited)