Adam Scott
Gary
Evangeline Lilly
Samantha
Owen Atlas
Lucas
Donald Faison
Larry
Chris D'Elia
Wayne
Kyle Bornheimer
Victor
Clancy Brown
Reverend J.D. Gospel
Tyler Labine
Karl C. Miller
Sally Field
Miss Shaylock
Marcus Terrell Smith
Dwayne
James Weir
Mac
Chip Zien
Stepdad Therapist
Rick Applegate
Principal
Ken Bolden
School Psychiatrist
Brad Williams
Gozamel
Allen Roth
Uncle Scott
Hank Harris
Gabriel
Carla Gallo
Wendy
Eli Craig
Derby Official
Russ Mitchell
Russ Mitchell
Paul Slimak
Homeless Albino
Schuyler White
Birthday Clown
Noah Craig
Jeremy
Mark Rademacher
Wedding Priest
Steve Kosinski
Priest
Cherie McClain
News Reporter
David Myers Gregory
End of Times Believer
Rhonda Freya English
Clerk
Peggy Miller
End Times Shopper
Sasha Williams
Mom at Waterpark
Michael Ryan Boehm
Annoyed Kid
Todd Emmett
Policeman #1
John Sundquist
Policeman #2
Ray Wise
Guy On TV (uncredited)
Kristephan Warren-Stevens
Little League Coach / Water Park Guest (uncredited)