Mandy Moore
Sadie Jones
John Krasinski
Ben Murphy
Robin Williams
Reverend Frank
Eric Christian Olsen
Carlisle
Christine Taylor
Lindsey Jones
Josh Flitter
Choir Boy
DeRay Davis
Joel
Peter Strauss
Mr. Jones
Grace Zabriskie
Grandma Jones
Roxanne Hart
Mrs. Jones
Mindy Kaling
Shelly
Angela Kinsey
Judith
Rachael Harris
Janine
David Quinlan
Expectant Father
Bob Balaban
Jewelry Store Clerk (uncredited)
Wanda Sykes
Doctor (uncredited)
Dylan Gentile
St. Augustine's Choir
Marie T. Hodgson
St. Augustine's Choir
Jess Rosenthal
Jewelry Clerk
Valentin Almendarez
Jewelry Store Customer
Nicole Randall Johnson
Louise
Tashana Haye
Church Kid Sarah
Sarah Kate Johnson
Church Kid Laurie
Travis T. Flory
Church Kid Manny
Dominic Swingler
Joel & Shelly's Kid
Devin Swingler
Joel & Shelly's Kid
Diego Swingler
Joel & Shelly's Kid
Cynthia Ettinger
Macy's Clerk
Gillian Skupa
Macy's Changing Room Lady
Poncho Hodges
Macy's Security Guard
Rubén Garfias
Coach
Kelsey Harper
Carlisle's Girlfriend
Irene Karas
Birthing Mom
Derek Green
Doctor
Christine Cannon
Delivery Doctor
Anelia Dyoulgerova
Belly Dancer
Nathan Barrett
Starbucks Customer
Darla Fay
Starbucks Customer
Sean Tyson
Starbucks Customer
Grant Gershon
St. Augustine's Choir Director
Crispin Barrymore
St. Augustine's Choir
Tania Batson
St. Augustine's Choir
Joseph Bazyouros
St. Augustine's Choir
Edie Lehmann Boddicker
St. Augustine's Choir
Paul Bent
St. Augustine's Choir
Cindy Bourquin
St. Augustine's Choir
Leanna Brand
St. Augustine's Choir
Andy Brown
St. Augustine's Choir
Karen Hogle Brown
St. Augustine's Choir
Vicky Preston Brown
St. Augustine's Choir
Alvin Chea
St. Augustine's Choir
Leberta Lorál
St. Augustine's Choir
Pablo Corá
St. Augustine's Choir
Claire Seely Fedoruk
St. Augustine's Choir
Amy Fogerson
St. Augustine's Choir
Rachelle Fox
St. Augustine's Choir
Michael Freed
St. Augustine's Choir
Michael Geiger
St. Augustine's Choir
Scott Graff
St. Augustine's Choir
Steven Harms
St. Augustine's Choir
Saundra Hall Hill
St. Augustine's Choir
Clydene Jackson
St. Augustine's Choir
Diana Zaslove Kahn
St. Augustine's Choir
Teri Eiko Koide
St. Augustine's Choir
Bob Lewis
St. Augustine's Choir
Sean McDermott
St. Augustine's Choir
Alice Kirwan Murray
St. Augustine's Choir
Bobbi Page
St. Augustine's Choir
Steven Pence
St. Augustine's Choir
Fletcher Sheridan
St. Augustine's Choir
Kevin St. Clair
St. Augustine's Choir
Cahen Taylor
St. Augustine's Choir
Carmen Twillie
St. Augustine's Choir
Winter Watson
St. Augustine's Choir
John West
St. Augustine's Choir
Gerald White
St. Augustine's Choir
Eyvonne Williams
St. Augustine's Choir
Cynthia Youngblood
Mom in Labor (uncredited)
Elizabeth Noelle Japhet
Church Goer (uncredited)