Tony Curtis
Louis 'Lepke' Buchalter
Anjanette Comer
Bernice Meyer
Michael Callan
Robert Kane
Warren Berlinger
Gurrah Shapiro
Gianni Russo
Albert Anastasia
Milton Berle
Mr. Meyer
Vic Tayback
Charles 'Lucky' Luciano
Mary Charlotte Wilcox
Marion
Jack Ackerman
Little Augie
Louis Guss
Max Rubin
Lillian Adams
Mama Meyer
Albert Cole
Gross
Zitto Kazann
Abe 'Kid Twist' Reles
Simmy Bow
Albert Tannenbaum
Russ Grieve
Judge
Clement von Franckenstein
Bugsy Siegel
Vaughn Meader
Walter Winchell
Johnny Silver
Schwartz
J.S. Johnson
Mendy Weiss
John Durren
Dutch Schultz
Barry Miller
Young Lepke
Jon Ian Jacobs
Big Hesh
Matt Greene
Skinny
Richard C. Adams
Thomas E. Dewey
Edwin Fuller
J. Edgar Hoover
Chuck Hayward
Doorman
Wesley Lau
First Detective
T.J. Castronova
Policeman