Edward Norton
Bill Kincaid / Brady Kincaid
Susan Sarandon
Daisy Kincaid
Richard Dreyfuss
Pug Rothbaum
Keri Russell
Janet
Melanie Lynskey
Colleen
Lucy DeVito
Anne Greenstein
Kent Jude Bernard
Philosophy Student
Amelia Campbell
Maggie Harmon
Tim Blake Nelson
Bolger
Randal Reeder
Shaver
Leo Fabian
Waddell
Pruitt Taylor Vince
Big Joe Sharpe
Tina Parker
Sharon
Ty Burrell
Professor Sorenson
Josh Pais
Ken Feinman
Lisa Benavides
Suzie Feinman
Steven E. Williams
Synagogue Parishioner (uncredited)
Maggie Siff
Rabbi Zimmerman
Tim Ware
Minister Davies
Ken Cheeseman
Jimmy Fuller
Steve Earle
Buddy Fuller
Lee Wilkof
Professor Levy
Jim Henry
Policeman (uncredited)