Nicolas Cage
John Koestler
Rose Byrne
Diana Wayland
Chandler Canterbury
Caleb Koestler
Ben Mendelsohn
Phil Bergman
Nadia Townsend
Grace Koestler
Terry Camilleri
Cashier
Lara Robinson
Lucinda Embry / Abby Wayland
Adrienne Pickering
Allison
Danielle Carter
Miss Taylor (1959)
Alethea McGrath
Miss Taylor (2009)
David Lennie
Principal Clark (1959)
D.G. Maloney
The Stranger
Alan Hopgood
Rev. Koestler
Joshua Long
Younger Caleb
Tamara Donnellan
Lucinda's Mother
Travis Waite
Lucinda's Father
Liam Hemsworth
Spencer
Harli Ames
Man in Duffle Coat
Alyssa McClelland
Flight Attendant
Gareth Yuen
Donald
Lesley Anne Mitchell
Stacey
Raymond Thomas
Teacher
Angie Diaz
Reporter
Kate Mylius
Student (uncredited)