Charlie Day
Peter
Jenny Slate
Emma Moore
Scott Eastwood
Noah
Gina Rodriguez
Anne
Manny Jacinto
Logan
Clark Backo
Ginny
Luke David Blumm
Trevor
Mason Gooding
Paul
Dylan Gelula
Lisa
Isabel May
Leighton
Pete Davidson
Jase
Giselle Torres
Chloe
Quinn Cooke
Taylor
Claudia Rocafort
Sylvia
Kysen Acevedo
Toby
Jami Gertz
Rita
Lauren Halperin
Janine
Thy Bui
Matt
Braxton Alexander
Middle School Boyfriend
Betsy Sligh
Middle School Girlfriend
Franco Castan
Audience Member
Jessi Goei
Waiter
Saya Watkins
Audrey
Manny Magnus
Seymour
Marco Schittone
Dentist
Polly Craig
Old Woman
Lynne Ashe
Receptionist
Yannis Kitas
Stage Manager
Ben McKenzie
Leighton's Dad
Spencer Murrill
Plant
Austin Seifert
Atlanto Bro #2
Kenneth Rouché
Pastor
Ava Ann Gale
Playground Kid (uncredited)
Chloe Camp
Birthday Party Kid
Linda D Gaines
Bar Patron (uncredited)
Julian Williams
Atlanta Bro #2