Lacey Chabert
Emily Melrose
Wes Brown
Jared
Ellen Travolta
Mary Louise
Peter Jacobson
Albert Melrose
Melissa Peterman
Pamela
Walter Platz
Bob
Alireza Mirmontazeri
Neighbor (uncredited)
Carrie Morgan
Gail Melrose
Eliza Hayes Maher
Jess
Kristoffer Polaha
Kevin
Eric Mabius
Allan
Jake Stormoen
Dan
Laura Wardle
Belinda
Lila Clark
Nicole
Charlotte Witt
Helen
Abby Villasmil
Young Emily
Manning Hazen
Young Jared
Mario DeAngelis
Tree Lighting Ceremony Attendee (Uncredited)
John Forker
Neighbor (uncredited)
Bebita Ndongo
Neighbor (Uncredited)
Mary Rice
Christmas Shopper (Uncredited)