Stewart Granger
Old Surehand
Pierre Brice
Winnetou
Elke Sommer
Annie Dillman
Götz George
Martin Baumann Jr.
Walter Barnes
Martin Baumann Sr.
Renato Baldini
Judge Leader
Terence Hill
Baker Jr.
Sieghardt Rupp
Preston
Milan Srdoč
Old Wabble
Miha Baloh
'Reverend' Weller
Louis Velle
Gordon
Gojko Mitić
Wokadeh
Dunja Rajter
Betsy (uncredited)
Voja Mirić
Stewart
Ilija Ivezić
Jackie
Đorđe Nenadović
Miller
Nevenka Benković
Settler woman (uncredited)
Šime Jagarinac
Schoschone (uncredited)