Mark Wahlberg
Father Stuart 'Stu' Long
Mel Gibson
Bill Long
Jacki Weaver
Kathleen Long
Teresa Ruiz
Carmen
Malcolm McDowell
Monsignor Kelly
Annet Mahendru
Mary
Cody Fern
Priest
Winter Ave Zoli
Allison
Faith Jefferies
Time Keeper
Ronnie Gene Blevins
Bartender
Ned Bellamy
Dr. Novack
Michael Fairman
Randall
Niko Nicotera
Barfly
Alain Uy
Tim
Carlos Leal
Father Garcia
Aaron Moten
Ham
Molly Baker
Mrs. Ferris
Chiquita Fuller
Waitress
Betsy Moore
Montana Sheriff
Tenz McCall
Young Stu
Penny L. Moore
Jenny
Tim Sitarz
Bouncer
Rudy Moreno
Market Customer
Nicholas A. Goldreich
Los Angeles Police Officer
Indie DesRoches
Sunday School Boy
Lily Villegas
Sunday School Girl
Roberto Montesinos
Carmen's Dad
Danielle Golden
EMT
Sharmila Devar
Los Angeles Nurse
Sean O'Reilly
Father Kelly's Secretary
James Flavin
Bishop
Jorge-Luis Pallo
Gael
Clay Wilcox
AA Chairperson
Lila Karp-Ziring
Medieval Background Girl
Steve Olson
Medieval Set Assistant Director
Dennis Keiffer
Medieval Bad Guy
Travis Wong
Medieval Knight
Bryan Kreutz
Bar Patron
Larry Bagby
Bartender
Mathew Trent Hunnicutt
Bar Patron
Mariah Maison
Cute Big Sky Nurse
Tyler Burke
21 year old Kid
Skip Howland
Boxing Judge
Pablo Ramos
Church Parishioner
Brian Ortega
Boxer #2