Edmond O'Brien
Timothy MacDonald
Michael Pataki
Rev. Paul Jessie Bundy
Marc Lawrence
The Undertaker
Brooke Mills
Grace MacDonald
Paul Prokop
Dr. Patrick Bundy
Arthur Franz
John
D.J. Anderson
Shirley
Nadyne Turney
Orphanage Director
Vicki Schreck
Grace as a Child
William Guhl
Sheriff Mike Pender
Pearl Shear
Mrs. Jordan, Shirley's Landlady
Elizabeth Ross
Hospital Receptionist
Mary Carver
Policewoman
Jay Scott
Deputy Sheriff
Tony Vorno
Bum at Landfill (uncredited)