Danny DeVito
Buddy Hall
Matthew Broderick
Steve Finch
Kristin Davis
Kelly Finch
Kristin Chenoweth
Tia Hall
Alia Shawkat
Madison Finch
Dylan Blue
Carter Finch
Kelly Aldridge
Ashley Hall
Sabrina Aldridge
Emily Hall
Jorge Garcia
Wallace
Fred Armisen
Gustave
Gillian Vigman
Gerta
Ryan Devlin
Bob Murray
Sean O'Bryan
Mayor Young
Su-chin Pak
Self
Jackie Burroughs
Mrs. Ryor
Garry Chalk
Sheriff Dave
Nicola Peltz Beckham
Mackenzie
Zak Santiago
Fireworks Guy
Daniel Bacon
Ed
Ken Kramer
Mr. Murray
Jill Morrison
Gail
Alf Humphreys
Hardware Store Employee
Brenda Crichlow
News Reporter #1
Jill Krop
Reporter #2
Agam Darshi
News Producer
David Stuart
Oblivious Dad
Quinn Lord
Santa Kid
Nathaniel DeVeaux
Main Street Passerby #1
Fulvio Cecere
Town Passerby
Eliza Norbury
Mary in the Manger
Randi Lynne
Caroler #1
Dan Joffre
Caroler #2
Aurora Faulkner-Killam
Caroler
Melissa Howell
Caroler
Lori Johnson
Caroler
David Shaw
Caroler
Myles Wolfe
Caroler
Ty Olsson
Trucker
Stephen Holmes
UPS Guy
Andrew Hedge
City Employee
Cory Monteith
Madison's Date
Cassidy Bot-Devire
Little Girl (uncredited)
Aaron Craven
Businessman Dad (uncredited)
Blair Gorrell
Carnival Fan (uncredited)
Rachel Lana Li
Spectator (uncredited)
Lochlyn Munro
Ted (uncredited)
Kal Penn
Amit Sayid (uncredited)
Caroline Redekopp
Mackenzie's Mother (uncredited)
Arden Rhine
Woman (uncredited)
Calum Worthy
Boy On a Bike (uncredited)