Errol Flynn
Dr. Peter Blood
Olivia de Havilland
Arabella Bishop
Lionel Atwill
Colonel Bishop
Basil Rathbone
Levasseur
Ross Alexander
Jeremy Pitt
Guy Kibbee
Hagthorpe
Henry Stephenson
Lord Willoughby
Robert Barrat
Wolverstone
Hobart Cavanaugh
Dr. Bronson
Donald Meek
Dr. Whacker
Jessie Ralph
Mrs. Barlow
Forrester Harvey
Honesty Nutall
Frank McGlynn Sr.
Reverend Ogle
Holmes Herbert
Capt. Gardner
David Torrence
Andrew Baynes
J. Carrol Naish
Cahusac
Pedro de Cordoba
Don Diego
George Hassell
Governor Steed
Harry Cording
Kent
Leonard Mudie
Baron Jeffreys
Ivan F. Simpson
Prosecutor
Stuart Casey
Capt. Hobart
David Cavendish
Lord Gildoy
Mary Forbes
Mrs. Steed
E. E. Clive
Clerk of the Court
Colin Kenny
Lord Chester Dyke
Maude Leslie
Mrs. Baynes
Gardner James
Slave
Vernon Steele
King James
Matthew Beard
Governor's Attendant (uncredited)
Yola d'Avril
Girl in Tavern (uncredited)
Halliwell Hobbes
Lord Sunderland (uncredited)
Murray Kinnell
Court Clerk (uncredited)
Chris-Pin Martin
Sentry (uncredited)
James Pier Mason
Pirate (uncredited)
Paul Panzer
Pirate (uncredited)
Frank Puglia
French Officer (uncredited)
Georges Renavent
French Captain (uncredited)
Jim Thorpe
Pirate (uncredited)
Louis Mercier
Pirate (uncredited)
Tom Steele
Pirate (uncredited)
William Yetter Sr.
Pirate (uncredited)