James Stewart
Tom Jeffords
Jeff Chandler
Cochise
Debra Paget
Sonseeahray 'Morningstar'
Basil Ruysdael
General Oliver
Will Geer
Rancher
Joyce Mackenzie
Terry
Arthur Hunnicutt
Milt Duffield
Robert Adler
Lonergan - Stage Driver
Trevor Bardette
Stage Passenger
Chris Willow Bird
Nochalo
Raymond Bramley
Col. Bernall
Chet Brandenburg
Miner
Argentina Brunetti
Nalikadeya - Cochise's Wife
Harry Carter
Miner
Iron Eyes Cody
Teese, Court Jester
J.W. Cody
Pionsenay - Chosen Warrior
Heinie Conklin
Townsman
John Doucette
Mule Driver
Nacho Galindo
Barber
Robert Griffin
John Lowrie
Jack Kenny
Townsman
Bob Kortman
Minor Role
Mickey Kuhn
Bob Slade
Al Kunde
Townsman
Ted Mapes
Mail Rider
Frank McGrath
Barfly
Charles Morton
Townsman
Jay Silverheels
Geronimo
Charles Soldani
Skinyea - Chosen Warrior
John War Eagle
Nahilzay
Billy Wilkerson
Juan
Bud Wolfe
Man
Richard Van Opel
Bernall's Adjutant (uncredited)
Dorothy Teters
Indian (uncredited)
Allen D. Sewall
Barfly (uncredited)
John Rice
Townsman (uncredited)
Edwin Rand
Sergeant (uncredited)
John Marston
Maury (uncredited)
Jack Lee
Boucher (uncredited)