Kim Director
Kim Diamond
Jeffrey Donovan
Jeffrey "Jeff" Patterson
Erica Leerhsen
Erica Geerson
Tristine Skyler
Tristen Ryler
Stephen Barker Turner
Stephen Ryan Parker
Lanny Flaherty
Sheriff Cravens
Lauren Hulsey
Eileen Treacle
Raynor Scheine
Rustin Parr
Kennen Sisco
Peggy
Dina Napoli
Reporter
Joe Berlinger
Burkittsville Tourist
Pete Burris
MBI Man
Briton Green
Stoner
Anja Baron
Tourist
Kurt Loder
Kurt Loder
Chuck Scarborough
Chuck Scarborough
Conan O'Brien
Self (archive footage)
Andy Richter
Self (archive footage)
Bruce D. Reed
Burkittsville Resident #1
Sara Phillips
Burkittsville Tourist #2
Lynda Millard
Burkittsville Resident #2
Deb Burgoyne
Burkittsville Resident #3
Andrea Cox
Burkittsville Resident #4
Erik Jensen
Stoner #2
Peggy K. Chang
Foreigner #1
Tony Tsang
Foreigner #2
Kevin Murray
Doctor
Keira Naughton
Nurse
Ed Sala
MBI Man #2
Tyler Zeisloft
Teenager #1
Richard Kirkwood
Teenager #2
Justin Fair
Teenager #3
Brilane Bowman
Ham Lady
Robert M. Kelly
MBI Man #3
Landra Booker
Reporter, Fox 45
Jacqui Allen
Reporter
Sloane Brown
Reporter, WJZ 13
Karen Tsen Lee
(voice)
Heidi Burger
Print Reporter
Brian Dragonuk
Angry Citizen at Courthouse
Armen Garo
Doctor
Nasi Glekas
Security Guard
Cathy Haase
First Nurse
Oscar Haynes
Videographer
Rick Kain
On Camera News Reporter
Julie Mabry
Hiker in Woods
Martin Pfefferkorn
Mental Patient
Chad Ridgely
Photographer
Heather Donahue
Heather Donahue (archive footage) (uncredited)
Joshua Leonard
Joshua Leonard (archive footage) (uncredited)
Michael C. Williams
Michael Williams (archive footage) (uncredited)